MLB Hall of Fame autographs from unlikely places

This site uses eBay affiliate links in posts. By purchasing items from these links the site may earn money at no additional cost to you.

We all know that nowadays you can pull from packs cards that feature pieces of a players jersey and cards that feature a players autograph, but there are some other brands of cards that feature some pretty sought after autographs as well.

Before the ‘hit-market’ boomed- players were signing cards for brands other than Topps, Fleer, Upper Deck, Panini, etc., and for some players- these cards represent their only certified autograph cards. For the sets featured, food is the primary source for these sought-after signatures.  Cross-promotion with tobacco, soda and cookies has always been a huge part of sports memorabilia history, so it’s not a huge surprise that these cards can be found from large food brands.

Nabisco created its All-Star Autographs in 1993 that featured six players that are now in the Hall of Fame. Brooks Robinson, Phil Neikro, Ernie Banks, Catfish Hunter, Willie Stargell and also features the only certified on-card autograph of the late Don Drysdale.  According to, ” Don Drysdale tragically passed away between his signing the cards and the beginning of the promotion. Nabisco honored all requests until they ran out of cards on Drysdale.”

Though unnumbered, these cards did contain a certificate of authenticity from Nabsico. They were available for consumers who purchased specially- marked boxes and sent in two proofs of purchase with a fee for shipping and handling.  These cards range from $15.00 dollars to $50 for Drysdale (via

Nabisco All Star auto of Don Drysdale
Nabisco All Star auto of Don Drysdale




In 1999 Hillshire Farms released information for its promotion for a line of Home Run Heroes cards. According the the 2010 Standard Catalog of Cards, these cards were available ‘via a special offer from Hillshire Farms Meats.’  Baseball fans could send in a package and $4.00 for shipping/handling to receive stars like Ernie Banks, Frank Robinson, Harmon Killebrew, and Willie Stargell.  All currently Hall of Famers, these cards range in price from $15- $40 (via These cards don’t feature any logos, but they are framed in a nice black and gold border and contain basic stat info on the reverse.  For a player like Killebrew- these represent one of the few on-card autographs he has out on the market.  Definitely the player worth picking up from this set.

Hillshire Farms Frank Robinson autp
Hillshire Farms Frank Robinson autp



2 thoughts on “MLB Hall of Fame autographs from unlikely places

  1. Dano,

    I love this post on the Drysdale card. I recently picked one of these up and I didn’t realize that Drysdale had died in the middle of the promotion, or that the price varied for each of the different signatures in the set. I picked mine up in a trade and was surprised at how easily the other collector let go of the card, but also found several on Ebay since that were between 20 and 30 bucks. That’s a great deal for a certified autograph of a deceased Hall of Famer. Especially considering his certified cut autographs are often three digits. Love the posts and great reading.

    The Snorting Bull

    1. Yeah those food cards send people off because they aren’t “official”, but in the case of the Drysdale sometimes it’s all you get. Which only makes it that much more special. Glad you were able to grab one! Thanks for reading !

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: